North Yorkshire Lib Dems challenge council over school transport as key motions put pressure on administration

CBS
19 Nov 2026
NY Council meeting

The Liberal Democrat group have challenged Conservative-run North Yorkshire Council over its controversial home-to-school transport policy, after a motion to reinstate school catchment areas was narrowly defeated at Full Council.

The motion, proposed by Cllr Felicity Cunliffe-Lister and seconded by Cllr Matt Walker, was defeated by just 43 votes to 40.

The vote followed two years of sustained opposition to the policy, introduced in July 2024, which removed catchment schools from the criteria used to determine eligibility for free home-to-school transport.

North Yorkshire Liberal Democrats have consistently argued that the policy has disproportionately disadvantaged rural families, leaving parents facing additional costs, uncertainty and lengthy appeals processes to secure transport for their children.

Speaking during the debate, Cllr Andrew Murday said:

“I think almost every councillor who voted for the current policy in 2024 now has buyer’s regret. The changes which have come out of the review process just tinker around the edges and leave many parents and children in difficulty.”

Cllr Felicity Cunliffe-Lister challenged councillors to explain why catchment areas should not be reinstated, questioning the financial arguments used to defend the existing policy.

She highlighted concerns that the anticipated savings had failed to materialise, while additional costs were being passed on to families and the Council through fragmented transport arrangements, appeals and increased journeys.

She also challenged the suggestion that rural families enjoyed greater choice, arguing that they often had significantly fewer transport options than families living in towns and urban areas.

Cllr Cunliffe-Lister said:

“There are significant and very negative issues that the current policy has created, and how it disproportionately impacts our rural families. Despite all the fine tuning that might be proposed, without catchment being reintroduced, this policy will be a Tory legacy that will continue to haunt us. It will continue to be open to challenge and appeal. Many of us will remember Thatcher the Milk Snatcher. If this Council votes to continue to deprive children of their access to school, and divide communities in doing so, we know many will find it hard to forgive or forget. 

"The current policy, without the inclusion of catchment, will continue to deliver long term hardship and inequity.”

Despite the defeat, Liberal Democrats say they will continue to press for a fairer system that recognises the particular challenges facing rural families.

Unanimous support for planning motion

In another success for the Liberal Democrats, a motion proposed by Cllr Chris Aldred and seconded by Cllr Steve Mason, objecting to the Government's National Scheme of Delegation for planning applications, received unanimous support.

The motion raised concerns about the increasing transfer of planning decisions away from locally elected councillors and towards officers operating under national rules.

Councillors agreed that local communities should retain a meaningful democratic voice in decisions affecting their areas, rather than having planning procedures increasingly dictated by central government.

The Council will now write to the Government's planning minister, Matthew Pennycook MP, setting out its objections and requesting a reconsideration of the scheme.

Cllr Aldred said the motion was an important defence of local democracy and the role of elected representatives in shaping their communities.

Support for people nearing the end of life

Liberal Democrats also secured unanimous support for a motion calling for council tax relief for people with a terminal diagnosis who are within six months of the end of their life.

Proposed by Cllr Chris Aldred, the motion recognises the additional financial and practical pressures faced by people and their families during the final stages of life.

The Council agreed that officers should examine the financial implications of introducing the relief, with the proposal to be considered as part of the 2028/29 budget process.

Cllr Aldred said:

“When implemented this will provide relief to those who are nearing the end of life. I am pleased that it received unanimous support in the council today and we look forward to its implementation as soon as possible.”

Standing up for North Yorkshire communities

The meeting demonstrated the importance of councillors bringing forward practical proposals that respond to the concerns of local people.

While the defeat of the school transport motion was a setback for rural families, Liberal Democrats say the narrow result demonstrates the strength of feeling around the issue and the need for the Council to reconsider its approach.

From defending local democracy and securing financial support for people nearing the end of life to fighting for fairer school transport, North Yorkshire Liberal Democrats are committed to delivering practical change for local communities.

The party has made clear that reinstating home-to-school transport to catchment schools will be a priority. If the Liberal Democrats lead North Yorkshire Council after the May elections, they will put catchment back into the home-to-school transport policy, ending the unfairness faced by rural families and ensuring children have fair access to their local schools.

This website uses cookies

Please select the types of cookies you want to allow.